Skip to main content

News

..with you every step of the way!

News


11/08/2026

When Trust Goes Wrong: Why Choosing the Right Attorney Matters as Much as Making a Lasting Power of Attorney

Most people understand the importance of having a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) in place. It can provide reassurance that, if you become unable to manage your affairs in the future, someone you trust can step in and make decisions on your behalf.

However, while much attention is often given to creating the document itself, a recent High Court case highlights why choosing the right attorney is every bit as important.

A daughter who had been appointed under her mother's Property and Financial Affairs LPA was found to have spent substantial sums of her mother's money on luxury holidays, cars, dining and personal expenses. Following her mother's death, the matter came before the High Court, which ruled that she had misused her authority as attorney and ordered funds to be repaid to the estate.

Although cases like this are relatively uncommon, they serve as a stark reminder of the level of trust and responsibility involved in acting as an attorney.

What Does a Property and Financial Affairs LPA Allow an Attorney to Do?

A Property and Financial Affairs LPA allows you to appoint one or more people to help manage your financial affairs.

Depending on your circumstances, this could include:

  • Managing bank accounts
  • Paying bills and household expenses
  • Handling pensions and investments
  • Buying or selling property
  • Making financial decisions if you lose mental capacity

The powers granted can be extensive. In some cases, an attorney may effectively take responsibility for managing all aspects of an individual's finances.

Because of this, appointing an attorney should never be viewed as a simple box-ticking exercise.

The Importance of Choosing the Right Person

For many people, the natural choice is a spouse, partner, adult child or close family member. In most cases, that trust is well placed and attorneys carry out their responsibilities diligently and with care.

James Clarkson, Solicitor in Eaton Smith's Private Client team, says:

"Many people focus on having a Lasting Power of Attorney in place, but the more important question is often who you appoint. An attorney can have significant control over your finances and assets, so choosing someone who is trustworthy, capable and willing to act in your best interests is essential."

What Are an Attorney's Legal Responsibilities?

An attorney has a legal duty to act on behalf of the donor and must always put that person's interests first.

This includes:

  • Always acting in the donor’s best interests
  • Keeping finances separate from their own
  • Maintaining accurate records
  • Avoiding conflicts of interest
  • Following the principles of the Mental Capacity Act 2005

Importantly, an attorney cannot treat someone else's money as their own, even if they expect to inherit from that person in the future.

The recent High Court case reinforces that attorneys must exercise their powers responsibly and within the scope of the law.

Can You Put Safeguards in Place?

Yes. Every family's circumstances are different and there are several ways to build additional protection into an LPA where appropriate.

These may include:

  • Appointing More Than One Attorney

Having multiple attorneys can provide greater oversight and reduce the risk of one individual making decisions without accountability.

  • Requiring Attorneys to Act Jointly

For significant decisions, requiring attorneys to agree together can offer an additional safeguard.

  • Choosing Attorneys for Their Skills as Well as Their Relationship

Trust is essential, but practical considerations matter too. Managing finances, property and investments can be complex, so an attorney should be capable of handling these responsibilities.

  • Seeking Professional Advice

Taking legal advice when preparing an LPA can help ensure the right structure is in place for your circumstances and that any potential concerns are addressed from the outset.

Don't Let Cases Like This Put You Off Making an LPA

Stories involving financial abuse can understandably cause concern. However, they should not deter people from putting an LPA in place.

Without a valid LPA, loved ones may have no automatic authority to manage your affairs should you lose mental capacity. This can lead to delays, additional costs and the need for an application to the Court of Protection before decisions can be made.

As James Clarkson explains:

"Cases like this should not discourage people from making a Lasting Power of Attorney. An LPA remains one of the most effective ways to protect yourself and your family. The key is taking the time to make informed decisions about who will act and considering whether additional safeguards may be appropriate."

An LPA remains a vital part of future planning, alongside making a Will, considering inheritance planning and having open conversations with family about your wishes.

Health and Welfare LPAs

While this case concerned a Property and Financial Affairs LPA, it is worth remembering that there is a second type of Lasting Power of Attorney: a Health and Welfare LPA.

If the LPA is valid and the donor lacks mental capacity, Health and Welfare attorneys can make important decisions about:

  • Medical treatment and healthcare
  • Where the donor lives, such as remaining at home or moving into residential care
  • Daily care arrangements
  • Diet and personal care
  • Social activities and contact with others

The donor can also decide whether their attorneys will have authority to make decisions regarding life-sustaining treatment.

As with financial decisions, these powers involve a significant degree of trust and responsibility. For that reason, careful thought should be given to who you appoint as a Health and Welfare attorney, ensuring they understand your wishes and are capable of acting in your best interests.

Need Advice on Making a Lasting Power of Attorneys?

Choosing the right attorney can make all the difference to the effectiveness of your LPA.

The Private Client team at Eaton Smith advises individuals and families on all aspects of Lasting Powers of Attorney, Wills and estate planning. Whether you are putting an LPA in place for the first time or reviewing existing arrangements, our experienced solicitors can help you make informed decisions that protect your interests and provide peace of mind for the future.

To speak to a member of our team, contact Eaton Smith today on 01484 821300 or visit www.eatonsmith.co.uk.


Need Advice? We've been advising clients since 1927.

Get in touch for clear, practical guidance from our experienced team.